This is a truly superb presentation of one man's obsessive love of cine film. As he records his life through the twentieth century I couldn't take my eyes off it.
Harry Birrell Presents Films of Love and War
2019
Action / Documentary
Harry Birrell Presents Films of Love and War
2019
Action / Documentary
Plot summary
Harry Birrell was given his first cine-camera as a boy in 1928. He spent his life recording incidents great and small. Home movies of family events and fine romances now ache with fond nostalgia but Harry's life was also filled with far away adventures. This beautifully composed, captivating documentary plunders the treasure trove of Harry's 400 films and personal diaries to capture a vivid sense of wartime years spent in Bombay, the jungles of Burma and the mountains of Nepal. Narrated by Richard Madden.
Uploaded by: FREEMAN
Director
Top cast
Tech specs
720p.BLU 1080p.BLUMovie Reviews
A reel treasure
Could have done without animal sacrifices
Interesting film comprised mainly of 16 mms kodacolour films taken by Mr Burrell.I wish that the film had stuck to a linear narrative instead of jumping forward to his wedding.He must have been fairly well off as filming with 16mm was expensive,and having said equipment was even more costly.I agree with the other reviewer that the framing device was unsatisfactory.I can do without relatives blubbing.
Extraordinary social history
Coming across 400 home movies by anyone from the 1930s and forties would have been a social history treasure trove in itself. So it's all the more remarkable to discover those of Harry Birrell, whose cine-camera hobby expands from the standard family holiday larks into a vast, subjective record of the second World War on three continents.
What makes it more special still is that Harry was also, during the war years at least, an assiduous diarist. Hey presto, first person narration to accompany the images, given stalwart voice for the film by Richard Madden (who comes from Elderslie, a stone's throw from Harry's Paisley).
The effect is astonishing, taking us from the courtship rituals of thirties Scotland - beach romance on the Isle of Arran, cinema dates in a sooty Glasgow - through the six years of the war, mostly spent in the subcontinent with the Ghurkas, ever smiling into camera.
Occasionally, we also get the intrusion of newsreel footage to round out the big picture, but it's Harry's - mostly colour - footage that is the star. It simultaneously builds a portrait of a war and of a person increasingly defined by it, through his growing bond with the men, his fears, his longings and eye-popping shots, such as an animal sacrifice, in which the beheading of a bull has been decorously blurred for our benefit.
Perhaps what's most affecting is the growing impression that Harry is changed, both for better and worse, by his time in the war. The diaries stop in 1945, and when we find out that he married in the fifties, the information is tinged with a sadness for the other girl he fell in love with on the Arran beach. There's a profound sense of the passage of time, and the people who flow through a life.
If there's a flaw, it's only in an opportunity missed to provide a framing device that would have made even more of this Aladdin's cave. As it is, we get perfunctory breakaways to Harry's family 'finding' (not really) and tearfully responding to Harry's legacy. It's all fine, but you can't help feeling that these extraordinary films deserved a grander presentation.