To be honest I didn't have very high hopes for this film. However, that kind of situation can usually allow for one to be impressed. This, however, was not the case.
To say that it may have been the most difficult book of the seven to put to screen is really not that much of an understatement. It is by far the longest, and had the most going on throughout the book, with the Ministry turning into a full-blown cover-up organization and Harry and co. just trying to survive the bashing of Harry in the tabloids. Cue the worst possible script imaginable.
I can't be nice about this. I watched this movie by myself, which means I wasn't going to be influenced by friends or family. That said, this movie was ridiculous (and not in a good way). I felt like the movie was on light speed. It blew by from plot point to plot point to plot point so quickly that half the characters received the most minimal of screen time, including Alan Rickman's Snape, who looked shocked every time he actually got to say something, as half of his screen time involved no speaking, just standing around. Sirius was even further abused. He would look longingly at Harry as though he wished he had time amongst the cascades of events in the movie to just talk to him. Pathetic. Then, as if it couldn't GET ANY WORSE, Ginny is not even in the movie. I've watched it twice now, but she's not even present for any kind of role at all outside of her sitting at the table in the Weasley's house. Now, correct me if I'm wrong, but shouldn't the future WIFE of Harry Potter get a little more CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT than that?!
Well, typically, the answer would be yes, but character development was at an all-time low in this one, as the ENTIRE chapter on the O.W.L.'s which was very tense and interesting, was replaced with one exam seen, proctored by Umbridge and spruced up with some unimpressive CGI mischief. In addition, as the characters moved from event to event to event, they always seemed to be out of breath, and I couldn't tell if it was from all the running they were constantly doing or the breakneck pace of the movie. Everyone just kind of popped up to ask what was going on or, in the case of several characters, including Sirius, who had been my all-time favorite character in the series, just as enemy fodder. To me, every character in this movie felt like a throwaway, and when your movie is full of garbage, the best it can be is a garbage can.
Unfortunately, there are plenty of people who just liked the movie because it looks good. However, I'm not simply drawn to shiny things, I need some actual substance in my movies, so for me, this is honestly one of the worst movies ever made.
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
2007
Action / Adventure / Family / Fantasy / Mystery
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
2007
Action / Adventure / Family / Fantasy / Mystery
Plot summary
After a lonely summer on Privet Drive, Harry (Daniel Radcliffe) returns to a Hogwarts full of ill-fortune. Few of students and parents believe him or Dumbledore (Sir Michael Gambon) that Voldemort (Ralph Fiennes) is really back. The ministry had decided to step in by appointing a new Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher, Professor Dolores Umbridge (Imelda Staunton),who proves to be the nastiest person Harry has ever encountered. Harry also can't help stealing glances with the beautiful Cho Chang (Katie Leung). To top it off are dreams that Harry can't explain, and a mystery behind something for which Voldemort is searching. With these many things, Harry begins one of his toughest years at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry.
Uploaded by: OTTO
Director
Top cast
Tech specs
720p.BLU 1080p.BLU 2160p.BLUMovie Reviews
If your head spins when you see HP 5, don't worry, it's not just you.
My Least Favorite Up To This Point, Maybe Overall
With their warning about Lord Voldemort's return scoffed at, Harry and Dumbledore are targeted by the Wizard authorities as an authoritarian bureaucrat slowly seizes power at Hogwarts.
At this point in the series, the story takes a decidedly darker and more sinister turn. This could be because of the subject matter: the students spend less time in class and more time preparing for real world evil. It could also be the introduction of a new crew. Not only has the director changed (again) but the screenplay has a new hand, making the very feel somewhat off. I have not read the books, but I get the impression a great deal was left out to account for time and to make the plot run smoother.
The best addition to this film from previously ones is Luna Lovegood. She was apparently in the books for a while as a minor character but did not come on to the movies until now. Her role is fairly small, but important, and her character adds the one bit of lightness to this script (aside from possibly the Weasley's pranks). They cast the perfect actress.
What really stands out about this film is how political it is. Parallels could be made between this and the rise of fascism or McCarthyism. There is talk of order, obedience, conformity, the need for a government to have a firm hand and to protect its own butt when damaging information comes to light. We know from the previous film that Voldemort is back, and the Ministry of Magic likely knows it, too. But they go out of their way to deny this and blame other people for terrible acts that have occurred. This political act of protecting a reputation slows down the process of preparing for Voldemort and stands in the way of clearing Sirius Black's name. The outcome could have been much improved and lives could have been spared if the government was simply honest.
I believe this to be the weakest film up to this point. I did not care for the shift in spirit (the opening seemed more like a drama than a fantasy film). And i did not like feeling like parts were missing. The plot was almost made too simply, especially compared to prior episodes where mysteries had to be solved. There was no twist or surprise here, just a throwaway film to get you to the next one.
Playtimes over
Within the first 5 minutes you can tell the series has undergone a dramatic tone shift and I have to say I think thats appropriate since Voldemorts return at the end of Goblet of Fire means that it's time to put aside childish things. The big bad men are here and they don't care about hurting children. it's time to get nasty.
Gone is the frivolity of the first couple of movies where magic was cool and everything in this new and magical world was just wonderful to behold, a la World of Disney. The new director has taken some risks with style and approach and they've paid off brilliantly. Order of the Phoenix is probably the darkest of the five movies we've had so far, even more so than Azkhaban which was a step in the right direction for where the series would eventually be heading. There's very little "fun" in Phoenix and you can see why. The Dark Lord is back, it's no laughing matter and this movie actually sells that fact.
This (in the movie world at least) is where Harry Potter crosses the line from kids movie to grown ups movie.
Harry now has some serious mental scars (as well as his actual one of course) since the events of the previous movie which while lighter than Azkhaban, followed on well from that movie. The Ministry of Magic is in denial about Voldermorts return and are trying to control the flow of rumour stemming from the events of Goblet. To this end we have new teacher and Ministry stooge Dolores Umbridge. Pink and fluffy on the outside, crunchy and evil on the inside. She makes no qualms about re-ordering the law at Hogwarts putting the kybosh on anything even remotely fun and making the students lives a complete misery. What she put Harry through in detention was simply pure evil.
She wasn't quite how I pictured her from the book but Imelda Staunton played her with a deliciously bitter/sweet twist, all charming and proper in her righteous delusions with that "stab you in the back" thing going on. She was a nasty piece of work.
It is a shame that a lot of the content of the book was missing but it was a big book and although I can't put my finger on what wasn't in the movie (I read it a while ago now) it does sometimes feel that there should have more substance to a few areas, mainly the characterisation of some of the characters. Most of the major bits I remember from the book were in the movie. There's a pace here we haven't seen before, a new musical approach also puts a new twist on things and I think Harry Potters world seems to fit it's new clothes well. I'm eagerly anticipating what's next as I hear David Yates is also directing the Half Blood Prince (last I heard anyway) and since that book has zombies in it I think the new dark style will suit it awesomely thank you very much.
The characters all look much older than they're supposed to be in Phoenix but it also kind of works in it's favour. They all look like they have a bit more history and life experience behind them, they're coping with stuff that will age any kid and it shows. That's also testament to the acting as well. Here mostly all the acting is pretty good, Ron Harry and Hermione all put in good efforts obviously having gotten the hang of the whole acting lark. Gambon is good as Dumbledore but I do miss Richard Harris and keep playing what might have been his versions of Gambons scenes over in my head. When I read the books it's Harris I'm picturing. Helena Bonham Carter gives a kooky insane kind of air to Bellatrix Lestrange (must get that from hubby Tim Burton) who was a pretty good character. One thing about this film though is that the actual Order of the Phoenix isn't in it all that much really. A flaw that wasn't in the book. The line about Snape being in the order, if you missed it you wouldn't even know he was in the order at all and a subsequent scene later on might seem confusing.
Kreacher was well done I though, coming across as a real miserable old bugger which was appropriate. The producers apparently weren't going to put him in the movie at all but JK Rowling said they'd be stuffing themselves up for the final movie if they did that.
All in all I think Phoenix is the best so far of the five movies, followed by Azkhaban, Goblet, then the other two in no particular order.
Now I've just got hold of The Deathly Hallows and although it's quarter past five I'm off to bed so see you later....