Doris Day, as an American married to an Englishman, is being terrorized in "Midnight Lace," also starring Rex Harrison, Myrna Loy, Roddy Mcdowall, and John Gavin. A scary voice speaks in the fog and calls her up on the phone - but she can't get anyone to believe her, even her beloved aunt (Loy) who wants to help but has her suspicions about her niece's mental health. The "midnight lace" is a neat title that refers to some sexy pajamas Kit (Day) buys for her Venetian trip with her husband (Harrison).

The film is based on a play, "Matilda Cried Fire" and probably owes part of its plot to "Dial M for Murder," which was also a play and made into a film by Hitchcock. John Williams is on hand in this film as in "Dial M" as a police inspector.

Unlike "Dial M for Murder," the film abounds with red herrings, so there are plenty of suspects. Roddy Mcdowall is the slimy son of Kit's housekeeper, and John Gavin is an attractive man who at one point comes to her rescue. There's also her neighbor, Peggy (Natasha Thompson). The acting is very good, the biggest and most dramatic role belonging to Day. Few people have enjoyed the variety of career that Day did. A wholesome-looking singer and vivacious actress, she was in in films from 1948. When she was in her late thirties, producer Ross Hunter took advantage of her prettiness and beautiful figure and moved her into glamor roles, making her the #1 box office star. If she's a little over the top in spots here, it's more the material than the actress, and she creates a very sympathetic and likable character. Loy, at 55, is beautiful and sexy. Harrison doesn't have a great deal to do, and Gavin is - well, Gavin, very handsome and charming. Herbert Marshall is part of the cast as well, and along with McDowall, Williams, and Thompson, make up a strong supporting cast.

This movie isn't as good as some others of the same type, but it is very enjoyable and well produced. One of those great Sunday afternoon movies.

Some trivia: A poster mentions that Harrison was distracted during the film because of the death of his wife, Kay Kendall. He was also distracted by the fact that he and Roddy McDowell had done a play together, for which McDowell had won a Tony. The elevator scene where they are all in the elevator together took a while to film so they were all stuck in a small space. McDowell said something and Harrison said, "Yes, and you can stick that Tony up your a** too."

"Midnight Lace" is entertaining and you can enjoy it provided you've not see "Dial M for Murder" and provided the ending doesn't irritate you...which it could easily do. But it's far from Doris Day's best...and should have been better.

The film finds an American, Kit (Day),being tormented by some unseen stalker. But the stalker is a very clever one and apart from Day, there's no one who has witnessed these threats to kill her. Some of these threats consist of a strange voice in the fog and others phone calls...and as they occur, Kit responds by screaming...a lot! Who is behind all this and does Kit stand a chance of surviving this ordeal?

The biggest problem with this film is that it is almost exactly like "Dial M for Murder". And, if you've seen it, you'll likely guess what's going to happen...and you'd be right on the mark. Even one of the characters is the killer from "Dial M"! So, to me, the film is very lazy and lacks originality. The second biggest problem is the ending...which seems incredibly contrived and a bit ludicrous. Why describe the entire plot to Kit before killing her? Just kill her!! In fact, as I watched the ending, I found myself feeling a bit angry....it's all just fit together TOO well...and seemed like a movie and not what could happen in real life.

So, despite some decent performances and lots of crying and screaming by Doris Day, the film is a disappointment. It is tense, it has some very nice moments but ultimately it lacks much to make it anything other than a time-passer.

"Midnight Lace" is an example of a film that does have its problems, but still manages to entertain you and draw you in. It is far fetched and somewhat predictable, and I admit for me the ending was so complicated I had to re watch it to maintain my full understanding. Also there are some loose ends that aren't as well explained as they could have been.John Gavin, while really handsome, is rather bland acting wise. With its flaws though, it is perfectly watchable and entertaining helped by the stylish filming, excellent music score and the fine acting. There are some effective scenes such as when Kit falls into complete hysteria(I will explain later what I thought of Doris Day's acting in that scene),the very first scene in the fog and the elevator scene. Also the voice on the telephone; very chilling. The film's style is strongly reminiscent of an Alfred Hitchcock film, with beautiful cinematography and Day's costumes are fabulous. The music score is truly atmospheric and made most scenes from the film quite tense and suspenseful, the direction is precise enough and there is some decent scripting on the whole. Aside from Gavin, who wasn't entirely insufferable just bland, the acting was well done. Rex Harrison is very suave as the husband, Roddy MacDowell is delightfully creepy, Hermione Baddeley is great and Myrna Loy is a real scene stealer. The best performance definitely comes from Doris Day; I love her in musicals, I love her in comedy, here she shows how wonderful she equally is in drama. Her performance here is outstanding, no overacting as far as I can see, her hysteria scene was so believable and almost heart-breaking. I had difficulty hiding my dismay when I saw the reviews that accused Day of overacting. Overall, it does have its problems, but it is one movie I would definitely see again for especially Day's performance and her costumes. 7/10 Bethany Cox