At the end of the movie, this message comes on screen - "The film you have just seen was an improvisation". That would partly explain it's disjointed feel at times, along with some inconsistency with the characters, in particular Lelia (Lelia Goldoni),who describes her first sexual experience with Tony (Anthony Ray) as 'awful', but in the next scene tells him how she's madly in love with him. By way of petty insult, she makes another beau, Davey (David Jones),wait two and a half hours while she fusses with her looks. I would have taken her brother Hugh's (Hugh Hurd) advice to not put up with it myself.
Made and set in the late Fifties, the film has a jazzy street vibe, with more than a passing share of Beat Generation influence, as director John Cassavetes cultivates a 'slice of life' picture that does have the feel of improv much of the time. Not quite midway into the picture, the tone of the story changes once Tony becomes aware that Lelia is a lightly skinned black woman who easily passes for white. Considering that she really is a white woman, born Lelia Vita Rizzuto, the improv factor becomes apparent more than ever. Upon reflection, Tony's love for Lelia is stronger than racial bias, and suggests to her brother Ben (Ben Carruthers) that there's 'no difference between us' as a way of smoothing over his earlier distancing from Hugh and Ben.
It strikes me that this was probably a pretty brave project for Cassavetes to undertake back in the day while notable segregation was still a fact in Fifties America. Cinematically it is rather amateurish at times, but makes up for it with a healthy dose of street energy and drive. A slight distraction for this viewer was the appearance of character Rupert (Rupert Crosse),who I would have easily taken for Laurence Fishburne in an early role.
Shadows
1958
Action / Drama / Music / Romance
Shadows
1958
Action / Drama / Music / Romance
Keywords: jazzpassing for white
Plot summary
Benny's a hipster, moving in and out of Manhattan's beat scene, aimless, maybe close to trouble. His sister Lelia, who looks less African-American than White, is vulnerable and about to fall in love. Hugh, their older brother, is a struggling singer whose agent, Rupert, may be the only person with faith in his talent. The story moves back and forth, like jazz, among the three of them and what seems at first to be separate lives. Lelia meets Tony, and lets herself hope this is true love. Then he meets Hugh and prejudice gives Tony an excuse to cut and run. Can family and friendship bring solace for her hurt, purpose for Benny, and belief in Hugh? Is life more than shadows?
Uploaded by: FREEMAN
Director
Top cast
Tech specs
720p.BLU 1080p.BLUMovie Reviews
"It's not a question of understanding it, man, if you feel it, you feel it!"
The Beginning of Modern Independent Film?
John Cassavetes' jazz-scored improvisational film explores interracial friendships and relationships in Beat-Era (1950s) New York City.
How fascinating that the characters briefly discuss existentialism, the thoughts of Jean-Paul Sartre and put the film in the context of the beat generation. Those of us not having lived at the time may not be sure how influential Sartre was in his own day. He certainly still is today (2013),but it is nice to see how he influenced thought and film early on. Can any philosopher today claim to have such potency? Can the average person name a living philosopher?
The film itself may not be a Beat film, but the action clearly takes place on the edge of the Beat world. Much of the lingo (like "mad chick") works itself into the story, and there is, of course, the jazz theme.
The film is said to be an "improvisation", and one wonders to what degree there was a script and how much was truly improv. All the characters share their names with the actors that play them, making the lines much more blurred than in a strictly script-based acting job. This is not to say there was no acting -- the characters are all incredible.
Where this picture excels, though, is with racial issues. We see that racism is often really only skin deep -- a black woman with light skin is seen as white, despite having a black family, raised in a black community, and so on. How much should our skin dictate our identity?
Cassavetes successfully worked outside the studio framework, and while there may be a lack of budget and polish, what replaces it is a heart and soul the studio never had (and some might say still does not have today).
John Cassavetes' first
Benny and his friends populate the Manhattan street scene. His older brother Hugh is a talented but struggling singer. Their sister Lelia can pass with her paler skin.
The version I saw is dated 1959. It's the first theatrical writing and directing effort from John Cassavetes. The technical skill is sometimes amateurish. There are some bad panning camera moves. The closing text claims that the dialog was improvised. It's a micro budget indie. At least, Cassavetes uses the street level energy to his advantage. Mostly, this is about the edgy subject matter and one very powerful scene. It's a good predictor of his future in filmmaking. As for the story, I would start the movie with the three siblings together. I didn't understand their relationship for the first part until I read the synopsis before continuing. It needs to be clearer. All in all, Cassavetes is pushing the envelope and creating some real art.