The clothes and the likes are really the only thing that date this film. 35 years old, and it still holds up well. No CGI featured, and none required. I have not read the book of this film, so I cannot say if it is an accurate adaptation, in the spirit of the original. I will say that it is a well-produced piece of fiction. The plot is quite good. The writing is good, and has very realistic, great moments. Dialog is well-done, and delivered equally well. The characters are credible and well-written. There is a reasonable amount of development and background for them. The special effects are undeniably excellently done. They are convincing throughout. Nature itself becomes the threat, with realistic physics. The camera-work and editing are nicely done, save for an awkward cut or two. Cinematography is effective. The pacing is solid for the whole film. As far as the technical aspect goes, the film is great. The acting is of high quality. The kid isn't the most annoying ever seen. The tension is admirable. I haven't watched particularly many disaster films... in fact, this film may be 50% of the total amount... so I can't say if this is an outstanding one. I'm not sure you can really watch this without noticing the theme of passivity versus activity... or, blind faith versus a more critical, independent faith. The film takes a definite stance on that. All in all, entertaining and worth your time. I recommend this to any fan of the actors and/or the genre. 7/10

In some ways "The Poseidon Adventure" is a bad film. The dialog is occasionally goofy and the characters are mostly caricatures. But you come to expect that from producer Irwin Allen....as his shows and movies were all about spectacle and disaster and had little in the way of realistic human interactions. In these ways, his films are a bit like Cecil B. DeMille's.

I just saw "The Poseidon Adventure" today. It was my second time--the first was in the theater when I was a boy. Both times I enjoyed it....but this time I could really see how cartoony many of the folks were in the film. There's the preacher (Gene Hackman)...a profane man who curses a lot and seems to have no faith in anything but himself. Then, there's the obese lady (Shelley Winters) and there are quite a few fat remarks at her expense in the film. And, there's the angry man (Ernest Borgnine) and his ex-prostitute wife (Stella Stevens). There are more...all seemingly one-dimensional characters occupying this disaster-fest. But, oddly, despite itself the film IS entertaining and you won't be bored watching it. The special effects are amazing and the film satisfying if, at times, a bit silly.

There may be some implausibilities in the story, but The Poseidon Adventure is by far one of the better disaster movies I have seen.

The special effects here are truly remarkable, as a matter of fact on a visual and technical level The Poseidon Adventure is flawless. The cinematography is beautiful, the editing is crisp and the set pieces are lovingly-rendered. The direction is fine too, and the score is never overpowering but hugely effective and the script is intelligent.

The acting is what makes the film though, special effects aside. Shelley Winters, Ernest Borgnine, Red Buttons and Stella Stevens all give wonderfully poignant performances, but it is Gene Hackman who gives the best acting performance of the movie. Call me brash, but Hackman's performance could very well be the only component that is actually better than the special effects, if that was humanly possible, what I am saying is that Hackman is brilliant here. Overall, a very stylish and entertaining film. 8/10 Bethany Cox