Long, incoherent, and unfocused. Uninteresting dialog replaced action. A little effort could have made the movie much better, such as something to make the characters interesting (within the movie).

This true story is not so uncommon - chasing the American Dream in whatever way possible, yet being able to bond with your child, albeit as an absentee father. At first I wondered why this story was chosen to be made into a film, as I'm sure there were better options. However, director and actor Sean Penn and his newb actor daughter Dylan Penn were outstanding with their performances, and made this film very powerful, touching and emotional. Although Dylan was monotonic for the most part, you could really feel the chemistry and bond her character had, and I'm sure is was much easier the fact it really was her dad. For that matter, every performance was pretty much perfect.

Penn's directing was also decent, and I had no problems with the time-line story telling, but I did find the 109 min runtime and the slow pacing drag out the story more than it should have. The screenplay felt a little scattered in some places, and I would've liked to see more father-daughter dynamics in the story. Cutting out about 10-20 mins from the adapted screenplay by Jez Butterworth would've done this film justice, and you wouldn't have lost any of the stories substance. The soundtracks, although very fitting, were too long and too many imo.

Nevertheless, it's a good story told well, that I enjoyed regardless of its flaws. I guess maybe I'm a little biased being a father and having a daughter that age, and a longtime fan of the Penns, but I still do recommend it, and will say the critics really went too hard on this one. It's a well deserved 7.5 rounded up to an 8/10 from me.

As "Flag Day" (2021 release; 108 min.) opens, it is "June, 1992" and John (the character played by Sean Penn) is being chased by a police helicopter and a slew of police cars. Along the way we are reminded that the film is "based on a true story". We then go back in time to "Summer 1975", where we get to know John and his daughter Jennifer, then 11 yrs young, as he teaches her how to drive a car (she sits on his lap and he falls asleep, no, really). At home, John is fighting a lot with his wife, much to the chagrin of Jennifer and her brother Nick. At this point we are 10 min into the movie, but to tell you more of the plot would spoil your viewing experience, you'll just have to see for yourself how it all plays out.

Couple of comments: this is the first film where Sean Penn directs AND stars (he has directed others before, at times with excellent result, look no further than "Into The Wild"). Here he brings to the big screen the memoir of Jessica Vogel about the complicated relationship with her dad and the rest of the family. While in and of itself this could make for a great film, I'm sorry to report that it didn't happen. There are several factors: first, none of the main characters are all that likeable to begin with. Second, the script is simply very uneven and somehow cannot reel us in to the story. Third, the film's photography is horrendous: quasi non-stop extreme close-ups, with hand-held camera work, and constantly in and out of focus "artsy" looks, resulting in a quasi headache inducing viewing experience. You just wonder: WHY? On the plus side, it is great to see the Penn family, oozing with acting talent. Besides Sean, there is his daughter Dylan (playing Jennifer) and his son Hopper (as Nick). All that said, I was quite disappointed with the film, after seeing the promising trailer in recent weeks. It feels like a lost opportunity.

"Flag Day" premiered at this year's Cannes film festival to mixed reviews. It premiered in US theaters this weekend and I couldn't wait to see it. The Tuesday early evening screening where I saw this at my local art-house theater here in Cincinnati turned out to be a private screening: I was literally the only person in the theater. Given that "Flag Day" is unlikely to pick up strong word of mouth, I don't see this playing in theaters much longer. But of course don't take my word for it. If you are a fan of Sean Penn or Dylan Penn, I'd suggest you check this out, be it in the theater (while you still can),on VOD, or eventually on DVD/Blu-ray, and draw your own conclusion.